Judicial Misconduct in Indiana – Judge Banned for Life

The Indiana Supreme Court has permanently banned Judge Matthew J. Elkin (Howard Superior Court) after finding he engaged in “tyrant” behavior and serious ethical violations:

• Failed to disqualify himself from at least 11 cases involving his former clients

• Used a “Game or Jail” tactic to intimidate problem-solving court participants

• Made graphic, degrading remarks to a domestic violence survivor about abuse

• Showed favoritism to some litigants while demeaning others

• Offered housing through his wife’s rentals, let participants drive his car, and possibly misused court funds

“A presiding judge’s demeanor has an outsized impact … yet Elkin wielded his position of power like a tyrant.” – Indiana Supreme Court

Elkin resigned and is permanently barred from serving as a judge (effective Sept. 30) but keeps his law license.

Why it matters: Judges hold immense power over people’s freedom, safety, and futures. Misconduct like this erodes public trust in the courts — especially for vulnerable participants in drug and re-entry programs.

Take action:

• Demand strong oversight of “problem-solving” courts

• Support survivors & whistleblowers who report judicial abuse

• Push for transparent discipline systems so misconduct isn’t hidden

Disclaimer: This post summarizes information reported by the Indiana Supreme Court and local news sources (WKRC, WXIN). It is provided for public awareness and discussion only and is not legal advice. Anyone affected by judicial misconduct should seek qualified legal counsel or contact the appropriate disciplinary aut